Journal guide
Stonk Journal alternative for futures prop traders
Compare Stonk Journal with QuantLab Journal using sourced facts about price, platforms, futures imports, prop accounts, and research tools.
The short answer
This Stonk Journal alternative is for futures prop traders who need documented Tradovate or ProjectX imports and configured prop account limits. Both products have a free angle in the supplied research, but QuantLab is free during beta with open signup.
Stonk Journal facts below come from its captured pricing and features pages in MARKET.md section 1b. QuantLab facts come from the verified September 2026 feature inventory.
Stonk Journal and QuantLab Journal compared
| Question | Stonk Journal, per its site and public pages captured September 2026 | QuantLab Journal, verified September 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Futures broker sync | Direct broker sync is on the roadmap, so Tradovate auto sync is not available | Tradovate OAuth and ProjectX credentials, including Topstep; other brokers use CSV |
| Prop firm account tracking | Separate prop accounts plus rules for drawdown, daily loss, position size, and behavior | Profit target, maximum drawdown, drawdown used, and consistency limit |
| Price | Free $0 forever; Pro $10/month; annual pricing is not published on their site | Free during beta; no live journal billing system |
| Platforms | Web and offline-first PWA, installable on mobile or desktop | Web application; no native iOS or Android journal app |
| Backtester | not published on their site | Free candle-by-candle futures backtester with bars delayed at least 15 minutes |
| CSV import | Pro adds CSV import from any broker with column mapping | Mapped CSV import with normalization and duplicate protection |
Confirm Stonk Journal's current features and terms directly before choosing it.
Where QuantLab differs
QuantLab's documented workflow starts with futures trade capture. Tradovate connects through OAuth, while ProjectX accounts such as Topstep use a username and API key. You select the accounts to import. Other brokers can use CSV after mapping the available fields.
For a prop account, you can store a profit target, maximum drawdown, drawdown already used, and consistency limit. The dashboard calculates maximum drawdown and evaluates the configured consistency rule. It cannot replace the firm's official dashboard or current rulebook.
QuantLab's public tools include four opted-in bot journals and a free futures backtester. The backtester uses market bars delayed by at least 15 minutes. Historical reports cover NQ, ES, and YM from a five-year, one-minute bar store, and the bias board summarizes daily futures bias with supporting base rates.
When Stonk Journal is the better pick
Stonk Journal is the better pick if you want a free tool with a longer independent review history. MARKET.md recorded 205 Trustpilot reviews and a 4.6 TrustScore at the time of research. QuantLab is a beta product, so its public operating history is more limited.
It may also be the better pick if immediate open access is more important than QuantLab's documented connections. The research describes Stonk Journal as free, while QuantLab requires an approved email before signup. Those are distinct advantages in public proof and access. The source did not capture enough product details to compare broker sync or prop account tracking, so verify those areas yourself.
What the review research can tell you
The miner found no one or two star Stonk Journal reviews in the sources checked, so there is no in-scope quote to publish.
Use a consistent test for both tools. Import or enter a small group of futures trades, then compare date, contract, direction, quantity, prices, fees, and net result with the broker statement. Check how the journal separates accounts and whether it preserves your notes. If you need rule tracking, enter the current limit from the firm's rulebook and confirm the calculation using a result you can reproduce by hand.
A practical decision
Choose QuantLab when Tradovate, ProjectX, or mapped CSV import fits your workflow and you want configured drawdown and consistency fields. Choose Stonk Journal when its current feature set meets your needs and its established free product history matters more.
The best free tool is the one whose record you can reconcile. Do not interpret a TrustScore or a feature list as proof that your broker file will import correctly. Test one account before moving the rest. The prop firm trading journal guide covers the fields to check. QuantLab Journal is free during beta and requires email verification after signup.
Questions
Is QuantLab Journal free?
It is free during beta, with open signup.
Can QuantLab import a broker CSV?
Yes. You can map fields, import executions, and use duplicate protection.
Does QuantLab track prop account rules?
It stores configured target, drawdown, drawdown-used, and consistency values.
Review your own futures trades
QuantLab Journal is free during beta. Import your records, then check an idea in the delayed-data public backtester.